During a recent appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live, Selena Gomez addressed the infamous cake mishap that almost derailed her wedding to Benny Blanco. The singer-actor revealed that her co‑star Martin Short had inadvertently sliced a piece of the wedding cake before it was meant to be served, causing a moment of chaos at the ceremony.
Gomez recounted how the incident unfolded: “He apparently insisted no one tell me,” she said of Short, who was also a guest on the show. “They’d managed to put it together and I didn’t care. I was there, but I didn’t know what happened.” She added that when the cake was discovered to have been cut, she reacted with a mix of surprise and amusement.
Short’s Slip‑Up and the Aftermath
Short explained that he had mistakenly believed each table had its own cake and offered a slice to fellow Only Murders in the Building cast member Steve Martin. After cutting into the cake multiple times, he was warned that it was the real cake meant for the ceremony, which would not be sliced until an hour later. “I tried to fix it with a fork,” Short said, recalling the tense moment before the cake was repaired.
“I heard you ate my cake.”
Gomez laughed about the incident, describing Short’s reaction as “like a little dog with his tail between his legs.” She also expressed gratitude for Short’s attempt to make amends, noting that the moment would remain a memorable story for both of them.
Despite the mishap, the couple celebrated their nuptials in September 2025 at a star‑studded ceremony in Santa Barbara’s Sea Crest Nursery. The event drew about 170 guests, including Taylor Swift, Paris Hilton, Ed Sheeran, Ashley Park, and Jennifer Stone, and was shared by Gomez on Instagram the same day she announced the marriage.
Short continues to joke about the cake incident, even mentioning that it cost him an invitation to Gomez’s Friendsgiving party because “she was afraid I’d start destroying the desserts in advance.” The couple’s wedding and the episode of cake confusion remain a lighthearted footnote in their otherwise glamorous celebration.