Logo text [The following story contains spoilers through the 10th episode of The Traitors: New Blood.]
Ben McDonnell had just finished bingeing every episode of The Traitors when he got the call to join the fifth season of the Peacock and NBC Emmy-winning reality competition. The barrel racer living on a ranch in Texas with his husband, where he hosts his weekly comedy podcast It’s Ben a Week, accepted the gig, which he considers one of his biggest challenges yet, and quickly found himself heading to the Scottish castle to live with strangers and host Alan Cumming. McDonnell became the King of One Liners and the fan- and cast-favorite gay cowboy — until his elimination in the penultimate episode that aired last week. Related Stories TV Jason Benetti Will Replace Dan Hicks on Notre Dame Play-by-Play Saturday Following Sudden Passing (Exclusive) 'Dancing' Diaries After 'DWTS' Season 35, Mark Ballas Would Love His Wife BC Jean to Be His Next Celebrity Partner
“Every morning I would wake up freaking out [about getting eliminated]. And for some reason, the day I got murdered, I was so calm,” McDonnell says when speaking to The Hollywood Reporter after his exit. McDonnell went onto the show assuming his personality would make him a Traitor, but being a Faithful sent him away from the series with something more valuable than the $250,000 prize money. “I didn’t think they were going to love me for me,” he says of his castmates. “And that part was healing in an unexpected way, when you didn’t even know you were broken to be healed.”
What Happened Behind the Scenes
Below, when opening up to THR, McDonnell reveals a surprise for fans and his castmates (he’s actually a trained actor), talks about the hardest parts about filming, like giving up his phone (“People are going to think I’m going to rehab,” he remembers thinking) and why Cumming is a national treasure who inspired the name of McDonnell’s new piglet, Alan Cunningham.
As a trained actor who left L.A. for a Texas ranch, how did Hollywood pull you back for this show?
This experience was truly one of the most exciting acting experiences of my life. When you’re on a set, you show up to play a character, but then when the director says “cut,” you go back to being Ben. When you’re playing Traitors, the director never says cut. You are in character at all times. Even when the cameras are not rolling, you still have to play whatever character you’re showing up as. If you’re having lunch, you can never break character. You have to play it up the whole time.
I have a pretty large and loud personality, so I really had to tone it back, which was challenging because I want to be the center of attention. I wanna go be loud, but that’s immediately going to put a target on my back. I also didn’t tell anyone that I was an actor. I really leaned in to, “I’m this gay cowboy,” which is not a lie. I really am the gay cowboy. It’s just that the gay cowboy is more of a hobby than my career.
The producers hired me to play a game about lying and deceit. But the show is non-union, so there are definitely people there who aren’t trying to pursue an acting or Hollywood career. For instance, Abby L. didn’t even have Instagram before she got on the show. She’s an astrophysicist, so she must be a fan of the show and then applied. There are people from all different walks of life, which was amazing.
I went to BravoCon and saw this Traitors thing, and I remember asking my friend, “What is Traitors?” She was like, “You don’t watch Traitors?” I had never seen it. She’s like, “You have to watch. It’s the best show.” I was like, whatever. Then in Texas, we got an insane ice storm last January and here in Texas, when you get an ice storm, you’re stuck at home because no one knows how to drive.
AJ, my husband, came out one day like, “What are you watching?” I’m like, “Let’s just watch this Traitors thing.” I turn on one episode — instantly hooked. I binged every season of the U.K. show, every season of the U.S. show. Then two weeks later I got the phone call: “Would you be interested in The Traitors?” I was like, “I just binged it. This is crazy.”
Next thing you know, I’m at a Scottish castle with Alan Cumming, playing Clue, basically, in the middle of the Scottish Highlands.
Were you pursuing acting at the time? Or do you feel like it was lucky timing?
Acting has always been my main goal. As an actor, I never thought I would do reality TV. For a long time, I was opposed. I’ve had other offers in life for a reality show idea, and I’ve always been like, “You can’t do reality and be taken seriously as an actor.” I do feel there has been a shift. Like, 10 years ago when I was like, “I can’t be gay and be an actor because I’m going to be put in this box where you’re just the gay actor.” That is totally not the case anymore. You can be gay and play straight roles, you can be straight and play gay roles. It’s not as scary as it used to be.
So same thing with reality. You you look at people like our Ariana Madix from Vanderpump Rules. She’s on Broadway. She’s on an NBC show. She’s doing all sorts of stuff. There are so many different reality stars who are now pursuing scripted. So I guess it was not quite as scary, but scripted television and movies have always been number one.
I know you were hoping to be a Traitor. What was your strategy going in? And did your strategy change once you found out you were a Faithful?
I had only thought about being a Traitor. It was so set in my mind.. There was absolutely no question of me not being a Traitor. Stupidly, that did not even enter my brain. Preparing for the show, flying over there in the castle. At no point was I like, “What am I going to do if I’m a Faithful?”
So when I didn’t feel the tap on my shoulder, I remember being like, “Do I need to ask someone if didn’t feel the tap? Like, for sure, I’m a Traitor.” And when I was a Faithful, I laid in bed that night and was like, “Well, now what?”
If you’re a Traitor, it’s strategy all the way. You need to plan. You need to think 10 steps ahead. If you’re a Faithful, it’s a popularity contest. We are back in high school, and you need the Traitors to think you trust them so they want to keep you around, and you need the Faithful to like you so that they don’t banish you. You can watch every season of every Traitors in every different country. What you think would work with one group of people may not work with the next. You have no idea how different people will react.