By 4 p.m. Tuesday, the New York Yankees will either seal a major bullpen gap or signal that they’re willing to shell out for a closer over several seasons. The one‑year, $23.15 million qualifying offer to David Bednar is due that day, and the outcome will shape the team’s plans to rebuild a bullpen that has struggled to find depth.

While the offer would set a new record for a reliever’s average annual value, Bednar has the power to negotiate a multi‑year deal that could exceed that figure—albeit with a lower AAV—making a rejection seem likely. Even if he declines, the Yankees could still pursue him, though other clubs would likely vie for the same talent.

Bednar’s Value and the Yankees’ Bullpen State

At 32, Bednar is viewed as the top closer in free agency, with former Padres setup man Adrian Morejón also on the radar. In his 1½ seasons with New York, he posted a 2.39 ERA and 45 saves over 86 appearances, and he allowed just one run in nine postseason innings. The Yankees’ general manager, Brian Cashman, praised Bednar’s leadership:

“He’s a cool customer,” Cashman said last week. “We’ve been very lucky over the course of time for the most part to have somebody with a strong presence and great leadership to lead out there, and he checked all those boxes along with the performance.”
He added that the club’s goal is to surround Bednar with quality arms to secure late‑game wins.

Earlier this week, the Yankees secured lefty Tim Hill on a one‑year, $2.25 million contract with a $2.5 million option for 2028, and they’re eyeing Paul Blackburn if price aligns. However, Bednar’s expected contract would run far higher. Cashman declined to confirm whether negotiations for a multi‑year deal were underway before the Tuesday deadline, but the benchmark could be Williams’ three‑year, $51 million pact with the Mets.

Despite past caution after costly reliever deals in 2019, Cashman stated he’s “not afraid” to spend big for a reliever. Recent sizable contracts—including Emilio Pagán’s one‑year, $11.5 million deal with the Tigers and Evan Phillips’ three‑year, $35 million agreement with the Braves—could further justify a significant raise for Bednar over the $9 million he earned in his final arbitration year.

If Bednar signs elsewhere, the Yankees might look to Morejón, who could command an even higher price, or attempt to acquire a closer such as Trevor Megill, who just won a World Series with the Brewers and is entering the final year of team control. With Hill and left‑hander Brent Headrick the only confirmed bullpen pieces for 2027, the club also faces a potential Rule 5 draft deadline, with hard‑throwing right‑hander Carlos Lagrange as a prime candidate for the 40‑man roster.