Former Wild Orchid singer Stefanie Fair is set to receive a $70,000 payout after the Tennessee Board of Claims approved a settlement over a June 2024 incident in which a Tennessee Highway Patrol trooper arrested her for DUI while she was completely sober.
Fair, 53, was pulled over by Trooper Keith Velez for failing to change lanes while driving in Nashville. Velez claimed he detected a “very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,” a statement that Fair disputed, telling the trooper she had not consumed any alcohol.
Arrest and Investigation
Body‑cam footage shows Fair wrapping up a traffic stop when Velez nearly struck her. He reportedly told another trooper, “I just come up to the car, and it just reeks of alcohol.” Despite her insistence that she was not drinking, Fair was given a field sobriety test and subsequently arrested for DUI.
“When he said he could smell it, I knew it was corrupt. This is completely wrong,” Fair told WSMV4.
Later, blood work returned clean, revealing no alcohol or drugs in her system, and the charge was dismissed. Fair’s attorney, Ben Raybin, noted that sober drivers in Tennessee often have no recourse to recover costs after a DUI charge is dropped, making lawsuits the only viable option.
Raybin added that “if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,” highlighting the agency’s tendency to pursue unwarranted arrests. Fair is not the first sober driver to secure a settlement; the agency previously paid $75,000 to Thomas Manis, who was also wrongfully charged in December 2023.