Last month, Shane Gillis turned to the public to clarify the controversy that erupted after his opening monologue on Saturday Night Live on October 10. The comedian’s remarks about women “dressing like whores” at the gym had ignited a firestorm, prompting questions about why the joke was not excised before the live broadcast.
Gillis, who returned to host the show after being fired from the cast in 2019, explained that the monologue’s fate rested in his own hands. He told listeners on The Joe Rogan Experience that the network’s writers do not typically draft the host’s material; the responsibility lies with the comedian.
SNL’s Approval Process
During the interview, he noted that the show could have pulled the joke entirely, but he had not handed over a completed set for the writers to edit. He added that non‑comedians who write the monologues for other shows rely on a different process, but that wasn’t the case for his performance.
"Not to defend SNL, they don’t approve it. I mean, they could shut it down," he explained on The Joe Rogan Experience. "They could, but you don’t write your set and give it to them. Unless you’re not a comedian. I’m sure non-comics, they write the set for them. They have writers that write the monologue for them."
Reflecting on his earlier firing from the cast in 2019, Gillis said that the biggest challenge this time was not knowing how audiences interpreted the joke on social media. He recalled deleting all his posts immediately, leaving him uncertain of the public’s reaction.
In a lighter moment, he joked about possibly “bumping” the comedians who criticized him from their tour dates, but clarified that he would not take such action. He mentioned that an agent had suggested it as a joke, and he laughed it off.
The fallout from the episode has seen several comedians and actors publicly call out Gillis. Kathy Griffin, Dan Levy, and Inde Navarrette mentioned him on the following week’s episode, while SNL alum Ego Nwodim and SNL UK host Ania Magliano took him on Weekend Update.
Gillis’s most recent stint as a host followed his appearances in 2024 and 2025, after his removal from the NBC sketch comedy’s featured cast days after being announced in 2019. That decision stemmed from resurfaced videos in which he mocked Asian accents and used ethnic and gay slurs.