When the “Yellowstone” universe expanded into the CBS‑Paramount+ spinoff “Marshals,” Luke Grimes had to confront a difficult reality: his character Kayce Dutton would be on the screen without the woman who had been a constant in the original series. The loss of Kelsey Asbille’s Monica Dutton has become a central emotional pivot for the new show, and Grimes admits it was a major concern when he first agreed to the project.
“The thing I was most worried about doing ‘Marshals’ was doing it without Kelsey. That’s legitimate. Like I just couldn’t wrap my head around Kayce without Monica,” Grimes told ScreenRant, underscoring how integral Monica had been to the narrative of “Yellowstone.” “The rest of ‘Yellowstone’ was about people fighting over land, and I just loved my wife.”
Finding New Storylines While Honoring the Past
Grimes explained that once he accepted the premise of a post‑Monica storyline, he began to see the creative possibilities that lay ahead. “But then once I sort of, you know, could wrap my head around the fact that that was going to open up all these new storylines, like, we just have to make sure we do honor that and don’t try to skip over it or pretend it didn’t happen,” he said.
"They’re not wrong. They’re meant to feel that way. I’ve always loved a will-they, won’t-they kind of a storyline. I don’t know where it’s going, but they’re kindred souls, and I think the way that we’re sort of building that is really beautiful,"
With Kayce now paired with fellow U.S. Marshal Andrea Cruz, played by Ash Santos, the second season of “Marshals” hints at a budding romance that could help Kayce heal from the grief of losing Monica. Grimes emphasized that this relationship begins as a deep friendship, a foundation that could evolve into something more intimate.
One personal detail still in the works is when Kayce might remove his wedding ring. Grimes told ScreenRant that he and showrunner Spencer Hudnut are still discussing the timing of that moment. “But I will say he’s still wearing the ring, and … Spencer and I have talked about, like, when do I take it off? Are we going to make this a thing or is it just going to not be there one day? So we’re still trying to figure that out,” he explained, hinting at the delicate balance between honoring past commitments and moving forward.